pink background and tattooes white man with a big belly and no shirt raises his hands up as if in qusetion. text reads, "you ask, I answer" "what are the medical, social and moral models of disability?" "unpacking disability" "meriahnichols.com

You Ask, I Answer: What are the Medical, Social and Moral Models of Disability?

Please Share

This is an explanatory post about the definitions and differences between the moral, the medical and the social models of disability. This is a question asked of me recently. Please feel free to ask any question related to disability, career development and/or mental health and I’ll answer as best as I can.

You Ask, I Answer

I don’t have all the answers to disability related, mental health, career or parenting questions! But I have some.

If you have a question, ask away! You can tell me who you are, or if you are more comfie asking anonymously, that’s ok too.


Instagram
Facebook

A Reader asked, “What is the Moral Model of Disability? I thought there were only two models of disability, the Social Model of Disability and the Medical Model of Disability”

Wonderful question, fair reader!

I’m going to start from the beginning.

Frameworks – or models – can be helpful in understanding ways of approaching and better understanding disability and it’s place in the world. There are 3 main models of disability, social, medical and moral.

The Social Model of Disability

In a small nutshell, this model says that nothing is wrong with disability. It promotes the belief that the environment is the disabling factor, not our body/minds. This model says, “hey, make it accessible and I’ll be there!”

This model is about leaning into the disability experience and being exactly who we are, and crafting an environment and culture that supports access and diversity.

The Human Rights Model of Disability

This model is the child of the Social Model, and it includes the concept of Disability Justice. It takes the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) to heart as its main reference point.

The Medical Model of Disability

This model says that disabled body/minds are broken and need to be fixed in order to operate in this environment. This model says, “let me change myself so I’ll fit in.”

This model is about changing who we are to fit into the world around us: (ABA) therapy, medication, surgeries, cochlear implants and so forth all fit in here.

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

The Moral Model of Disability

This model says that disability has a spiritual purpose. Depending on the religion, this can mean that disability exists to teach people something (people around the person with the disability or the person themself) or as a penance for something done in a previous life. This model says either, “I am being tested by God!” or “I deserve this” or “I inspire others!” or along those lines.

This model wraps itself around inspiration and overcoming.

The Charity Model

This model is kind of a child of both the Moral and Medical Models. This model sees us as broken victims of our tragic circumstances, that we’re suffering and really need help and care.

The World’s a Kaleidoscope

While I’d love to say that all of us with disabilities are 100% about the Social Model (and it’s love child, the Human Rights Model), we aren’t. Plenty of us have internalized ableism. We’ve grown up being told certain things about ourselves, and over time, those things that we’ve been told seep into our marrow, often like a tumor.

I think it’s true to say that most of us have a mix of these models combined into the lens of the way we view ourselves and our world. I myself love my ADHD brain, but I also take medication because I need to be able to focus and meds help. I love my silent deaf world and yet I wear hearing aids, because I also like hearing when I want to. I don’t see myself as broken though – I see meds and hearing aids as tools that help me create the path that I’d like to tread in this world.

I feel the same way about my kids. I don’t slather my daughter with every which kind of therapy for a teen with Down syndrome; I pick and choose with her, based on what will help complement her life. With my sons, I don’t dip them into ABA because I think ultimately that makes the world less safe for them. They have individual mental health and neuro-affirming therapy, along with meds and careful attention to nutrition, exercise and sleep. All those are stories for another day though.

How Do I Help the Disabled?
Why Come Out as Disabled if You Can "Pass" as Non-Disabled?
Isn't Inspiration Porn Better Than No Disability Coverage?
How Do I Get Services for My Disabled Child?
How Can I Talk About Mental Illness?
What's the Deaf Experience Like?
How Do I Get a Service Dog?

You Ask, I Answer

I don’t have all the answers to disability related, mental health, career or parenting questions! But I have some.

If you have a question, ask away! You can tell me who you are, or if you are more comfie asking anonymously, that’s ok too.


Instagram
Facebook

Please Share

Read On